THE CARTRIDGE COLLECTOR'S EXCHANGE

Contents

Home

General Info

Ordering Info

Contact us

Cartridge Lists
Patent & Miscellaneous
Rim Fire
Center Fire Pistol
Center Fire Rifle
Metric Rimfire, Pistol&Rifle
British Pistol and Rifle
Shotgun Shells
Cartridge Boxes & Related

Posters

This Month's Picture Page

Index to Picture Pages

Prior Picture Pages:
 * September 2003
 
* October 2003
 
* November 2003
 
* December 2003                                * January 2004
 
* February 2004
 
* March 2004
 
* April 2004
 
* May 2004
 
* June 2004
 
* July 2004
 
* August 2004
 
* September 2004
 
* October 2004
 
* November 2004
 
* December 2004
 
* January 2005
 
* February 2005
 
* March 2005
 
* April 2005
 
* May 2005
 
* June 2005
 
* July 2005
 
* August 2005
 
* September 2005
 
* October 2005
 
* November 2005
 
* December 2005
 
* January 2006
 
* February 2006
 
* March 2006
 
* April 2006
 
*May 2006
 
*June 2006
 
*July 2006
 
*August 2006
 
*September 2006
 
*October 2006
 
*November 2006
 
*December 2006
 
*January 2007
 
*February 2007
 
*March 2007
 
*April 2007
 
*May 2007
 
*June 2007
 
*July 2007
 
*August 2007
 
*September 2007
 
*October 2007
 
*November 2007
 
*December 2007
 
*January 2008
 
*February 2008
 
*March 2008
 
*April 2008
 
*May 2008
 
*June 2008
 
*July 2008
 
*August 2008
 
*September 2008
 
*October 2008
 
*November 2008
 
*December 2008
 
*January 2009
 
*February 2009
 
*March 2009
 
*April 2009
 
*May 2009
 
*June 2009
 
*July 2009
 
*August 2009
 
*September 2009
 
*October 2009
 
*November 2009
 
*December 2009
 
*January 2010
 
*February 2010
 
*March 2010
 
*April 2010

 

 

Links to Other Sites     

Cartridge Collectors Organizations:
IAA
ECRA
SAAACA

Auctions:
Auction Arms
E-Bay
Ward's Collectibles
Sold USA

Books:
Armory Publications
WCF Publications

Other Collector's Sites:
Curtis Steinhauer

 

Home of the Old Ammo Guy's Virtual Cartridge Trading Table

 


Picture Page

May 2010


A UMC .44-40 box to watch out for (or beware of)......

Here's a box you may want to be on the lookout for, not because it would make a great addition to your collection, but because it is not everything that it initially appears to be. At first glance, it looks like a great box - in very good condition with all of its labels intact, still full of cartridges, and marked on one end for Colts New Lightning rifle and Frontier revolver. You could hardly ask for a better combination of firearms to be on the label for adding collector appeal to a box of cartridges. The more you look at this box, the more interesting it gets, to the point of being a little too interesting.

This box recently showed up on the International Ammunition Association's cartridge forum. Cartridge box collectors haven't had to give much thought in the past to fakes when dealing in boxes produced after 1900 by the major US commercial  manufacturers. About the worst thing you might have encountered would incorrect cartridges or a mix of cartridges in a box. There doesn't appear to be a problem with the cartridges in this box, nor with the box itself, but the labels are another matter. With the high prices being paid for even common caliber collector-grade two piece boxes made by such companies as Winchester, Remington-UMC, and the Unites States Cartridge Company, it had to follow that unscrupulous individuals who have a tough time making an honest living would soon begin to make their presence known to collectors of post-1900 boxes. This box points out the need for collectors to look much more closely at any box they are considering purchasing..

There are a lot of indicators that the labels on this box are not correct - actually, an overwhelming number. However, if not looked at carefully, and without a box from the same period to compare it to, a beginning collector or even a seasoned one could easily get duped. The color, wear and soiling of the labels are quite convincing, but they have problems with formatting and text that give them away. I have included pictures here of a genuine box of similar style for comparison purposes which will make some of the problems with the box shown above much more obvious.

The top label looks good at first glance; there are some formatting and spacing differences, but these might be expected from one label printing to the next. However, note that the cartridge on the label of the suspect box has a REM-UMC headstamp, which would be expected on a box made after the merger of Remington Arms and UMC, but not on a box made prior to the merger. In addition, the cartridge on the label appears to have a neck cannelure, which would indicate it is a smokless load, yet the '40 GRS POWDER' on the label indicates the cartridges are black powder loads.

The side sealing label displays a number of problems. Of interest are the firearms noted on one end of the box, the 'New Lightning Magazine Rifle and Frontier Revolver'. The inclusion of these Colt firearms on the label will add significant value to a box of .44-40 cartreidges. However, UMC boxes of cartridges that were marketed for the Colt firearms would be expected to have a Colt endorsement of the cartridges on the side label, with a 'Colt Patent Firearms Manufacturing Company' signature. In addition, UMC cartridges for the Lightning Magazine Rifle are quite rare, and are in specially labeled boxes. Further, the cartridge on the top label and those in the box would be expected to have the 'C.L.M.R.' headstamp. Since the top label on the suspect box indicates the cartridges are for the .44 caliber Winchester, I would expect the side label to reflect this also, as seen on the 'correct' box. 

The statement on the side of the suspect box above the UMC signature (shown in this picture) is very much out of character for this style box. The typical statement on these UMC boxes is in the form of a guarantee that the cartridges will function well in a quality firearm, as shown in the second picture. Such guarantees were dropped as the ammunition industry became more liability-conscious in the mid 1900s. The wording of the statement on suspect box provides undeniable proof that the box is not correct, as I found nearly identical wording on a box of Winchester .44-40 cartridges of the 'horse and rider' style that was introduced around 1981 after Olin Corporation had sold the firearms side of its business to the U.S. Repeating Arms Company.    

.

.

.

.

.

.

The guarantee label on the bottom of the suspect box is the bi-lingual (English and Spanish) style that was usually used on boxes intended for exportation to Mexico. I am not aware of these bi-lingual labels being used on UMC boxes; I have only seen them on boxes with the Remington-UMC labels; if anyone knows otherwise, I'd appreciate hearing from them. The bottom guarantee label should also include the 'Union Metallic Cartridge Co.' signature printed on the bottom right-hand side; it should match the style of the signature on the side of the box, although it will usually be smaller. The signature on the bottom label of the suspect box is illegible, but whatever it says, it definitely is not Union Metallic Cartridge Co.

.

.

.

.


A box of UMC .32 Long Rifle rim fire cartridges....

It is interesting to note that, while the inside lubed bullet was being used by the U.S. military as early as the 1860s for many of the rim fire cartridges, it took until the mid 1890s for some of the popular commercial rim fire and center fire cartridges to make the transition from outside lubed to inside lubed bullets. The .32 Long Rifle was introduced around 1900 as an inside lubed improvement to the .32 long rim fire. The case was a little longer than the .32 long, but otherwise, the dimensions were about the same. Both UMC and Winchester added the .32 long rifle as a black powder load to their catalogs around 1901; Winchester also produced it as a Lesmok load beginning in 1911. It was no longer listed in either company catalog following the end of World War I.

.

One thing that may have lead to its demise was that it had rather poor accuracy in the .32 firearms that it could be fired in, which were any of those chambered for the .32 long and extra long cartridges. No gun manufacturer produced a firearm specifically for the .32 long rifle cartridge. As the diameter of the bullet had to be small enough for it to fit inside the mouth of the cartridge case, the result was a bullet measuring .312", compared with the .316" bullet used in the other .32 rimfires, which was the reason for the accuracy problems.

 

 

 

.

.

.

.


An interesting DWM headstamp.....

The cartridge shown here is 9.3 x 74R Mauser, made since about 1902 and still popular today and manufactured by most of the European ammunition makers for use in drillings and combination guns. The cartridge shown here was made by Deutsche Werke AG (DWA) in 1920. According to W. B. Dixon (European Sporting Cartridges), DWA was established in 1919 to run the German ammunition factories and convert them back over to peace time production.

The 474A in the headstamp is the number assigned to the case by DWM. These case numbers were used only until about 1936. The stars were included in the headstamps of sporting ammunition  by the company and were dropped about 1920 and replaced by pairs of small letters, one on either side of the DWM to indicate the date of manufacture. Mr Dixon posted a variation of this headstamp to the IAA cartridge forum that includes small dashes next to the stars, shown on the right.  

.

.

.