THE CARTRIDGE COLLECTOR'S EXCHANGE

Contents

Home

General Info

Ordering Info

Contact us

Cartridge Lists
Patent & Miscellaneous
Rim Fire
Center Fire Pistol
Center Fire Rifle
Metric Rimfire, Pistol&Rifle
British Pistol and Rifle
Shotgun Shells
Cartridge Boxes & Related

Posters

This Month's Picture Page

Index to Picture Pages

Prior Picture Pages:
 * September 2003
 
* October 2003
 
* November 2003
 
* December 2003                                * January 2004
 
* February 2004
 
* March 2004
 
* April 2004
 
* May 2004
 
* June 2004
 
* July 2004
 
* August 2004
 
* September 2004
 
* October 2004
 
* November 2004
 
* December 2004
 
* January 2005
 
* February 2005
 
* March 2005
 
* April 2005
 
* May 2005
 
* June 2005
 
* July 2005
 
* August 2005
 
* September 2005
 
* October 2005
 
* November 2005
 
* December 2005
 
* January 2006
 
* February 2006
 
* March 2006
 
* April 2006
 
*May 2006
 
*June 2006
 
*July 2006
 
*August 2006
 
*September 2006
 
*October 2006
 
*November 2006
 
*December 2006
 
*January 2007
 
*February 2007
 
*March 2007
 
*April 2007
 
*May 2007
 
*June 2007
 
*July 2007
 
*August 2007
 
*September 2007
 
*October 2007
 
*November 2007
 
*December 2007
 
*January 2008
 
*February 2008
 
*March 2008
 
*April 2008
 
*May 2008
 
*June 2008
 
*July 2008
 
*August 2008
 
*September 2008
 
*October 2008
 
*November 2008
 
*December 2008
 
*January 2009
 
*February 2009
 
*March 2009
 
*April 2009
 
*May 2009
 
*June 2009
 
*July 2009
 
*August 2009
 
*September 2009
 
*October 2009
 
*November 2009
 
*December 2009
 
*January 2010
 
*February 2010
 
*March 2010
 
*April 2010
 
*May 2010
 
*June 2010

 

 

Links to Other Sites     

Cartridge Collectors Organizations:
IAA
ECRA
SAAACA

Auctions:
Auction Arms
E-Bay
Ward's Collectibles
Sold USA

Books:
Armory Publications
WCF Publications

Other Collector's Sites:
Curtis Steinhauer

Home of the Old Ammo Guy's Virtual Cartridge Trading Table


Picture Page

July 2010


Jabez H. Gill's reloading cartridge case....

A discussion on the IAA cartridge forum a couple of months ago centered around Gill's replaceable anvil, which was tested at the Frankford Arsenal in early 1877. While I had not heard of Gill's anvil before, I was familiar with the name Gill in reference to U.S. military small arms ammunition development. Jabez H. Gill started work at the Frankford Arsenal in 1864 as a machinist, working his way up to foreman and then draftsman, and in 1881 he was appointed as the arsenal armourer. He designed many of the cartridge making machines that were used by the arsenal for fabricating and loading the rifle and revolver cartridges that they produced. In 1879, he was issued a patent for the primer that was used when the Benet inside-primed cartridge case was phased out and replaced by an externally-primed reloading cartridge case. In 1882, he patented a priming and de-priming tool that was standard issue with the reloading tool sets produced from 1883 until sometime in the early 1900s.   

Gill was granted patent 190208 for a re-loadable cartridge case that employed a removable primer anvil on May 1st, 1877. The patent  covered a copper case with a thicker, stronger base and rim, and corrugations along its sides to help prevent the case from expanding to the extent that it became jammed in the rifle chamber upon firing. These improvements were intended to address extraction problems that at the time were thought to have been partly responsible for Custer's defeat a year earlier. Also covered by the patent was the tool that was used to form the inside of the head of the cartridge case and, almost as an afterthought, the three pronged anvil, about which he gave few details in the patent specifications that accompanied his drawing.  Gill's primer anvil was not an integral part of the primer pocket as was used on the Berdan case; instead, it was a separate piece from the case, and could be easily removed and replaced if necessary. The specifications are included below.      

According to James Zupan, author of Tools, Targets, and Troopers, on January 16th of 1877 Gill submitted his design for a reloading cartridge case to Major James M. Whittemore, the Commanding Officer of the Frankford Arsenal. Whittemore made notes on the draftsman's print of the design, which said in part 'This cartridge is intended to reload if necessary. The anvil is made and pressed in so as to be practically permanent, and will last longer, for the work required of it, than the case'. The draftsman's print, which is shown here, is from Mr. Zupan's book. Major Whittemore recommended that 100,000 reloading cartridges be produced for testing using Gill's case. According to an entry in a five page handwritten Record of Alterations and Improvements in Rifle, Carbine, and Revolver Ammunition, Cal. .45 prepared in 1878, which I received a copy of some years ago, production was begun on March 14th, 1877. These cartridges had Berdan primers and were loaded with 405 grain bullets, the standard rifle bullet at that time. They were also some of the first cartridges produced by the arsenal that had headstamps, as headstamping was commenced on March 22nd. The headstamps on the reloading cartridges were  R  F  3  77 and R  F  4  77.

 I have not been able to determine if the only cartridges produced for testing at that time were the 100,000 using Gill's case with its removable anvil, or if perhaps other reloading designs were produced. Unfortunately, the Report of the Chief of Ordnance for fiscal year 1877 does not have a separate listing for re-loadable cartridges in its totals of small arms ammunition produced in that year, nor does it contain any reports that address the testing of this ammunition. In addition, the labels on the boxes of this ammunition provide no information regarding to the design of the cartridge. The label shown above was copied from The .45-70 Springfield by Al Frasca & Robert Hill.

Another draftsman's print from the Zupan book shows two primers that were used in developing the reloading cartridge at the Frankford Arsenal. These primers are identified as 'J. H. Gill's Pat 1868 Frankford Arsenal' on the left side of the print and 'Hobb's Patent Bridgeport' on the right. I have not been able to locate an 1868 patent issued to Gill, but it would appear one benefit of  his primer design with its rebated edge would be to make de-capping of the case easier when using one of the Berdan tools that pierces the primer cup with a sharp punch in order to remove it. Otherwise, his primer appears to be of the Berdan style, consisting of the open cup and a pellet of fulminate. I have never seen this primer on any cartridge, much less a .45-70, so it is not likely that it saw any use beyond developmental purposes. Notice that this same primer using Gill's removable anvil is included in the sectioned case head shown at the top of the drawing. The Hobb's patent that is referred to is most likely A. C. Hobb's patent 94743, issued September 14th, 1869. It was an improvement in the Berdan primer, and covered sandwiching the fulminate between two layers of varnish to make it more water-proof. This primer is likely to be the one that was primarily, if not exclusively, used on the R  F  3  77 and R  F  4  77 headstamped reloading cartridges.  

It is possible that many, if not all, of the R  F  4  77 headstamped re-loadable cartridges were fitted with Gill's replaceable anvil. As I have only one of these cartridges in my collection, I am not inclined to disassemble it to determine verify that it has the removable primer anvil. I'd love to see pictures showing the details of one of these cartridges that has been sectioned if someone has one.  

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

 


A well-used old Colt Model 1860 Revolver........

In spite of the fact that much of my attention is focused on old ammunition, I like to think of myself as a fairly well-rounded individual, with interests in other things as well; I like old guns, too. I picked up the Colt Model 1860 revolver pictured below several months ago from 'Honest' Ron Huskey, a friend of 30 or so years and a collector of Winchesters, Colts, and other things that go bang, although pocket watches seem to be one of his latest interests. I have shared tables at our local Tallahassee gun show with Ron for many of those years. As is often the case at the Tallahassee show, not much happens from an antique gun and ammo perspective, as nearly everyone attending the show tends to be interested in new guns and ammo, and most of the sellers usually have their tables filled with an assortment of the modern guns, ammo and accessories that this mostly shooting crowd is looking for. Not so with Ron and me - we have antique guns and related items on our tables, and that's all we generally are looking for when we make our rounds checking out the other tables. As a result, Ron, Ron's wife Barbara, and I tend to spend a lot of time at our tables, which gives us plenty of time to talk and get caught up on what's been happening in our lives over the prior few months since the prior gun show. As is usually the case, by Sunday afternoon we are all talked out, and we typically get down to wheeling and dealing for something that caught our eye on the other fellows table. As is also usually the case, having not sold enough to recoup our table and food expenses for the weekend, we tend to be desperate for an infusion of cash, and therefore are not in the best frame of mind to be on the selling end of one of these Sunday afternoon transactions. The strategy as the potential buyer in one of these Husky-Hildebrand deals is to not show any interest in the item that you have taken a fancy to until Sunday afternoon, and to hope that the other fellow actually brings up the subject of a possible deal involving the coveted item, as this indicates that he is really anxious to sell. This is sometimes tough, as there is the slim chance that someone else will buy the item prior to Sunday afternoon. Everything went as I had hoped for with the Colt revolver, although I had a close call on Saturday when someone came close to buying it, but eventually changed his mind when he noticed the trigger and a couple of screws were missing.      

The revolver didn't have much going for it. In addition to the missing trigger and screws, it has mixed serial numbers, the barrel and cylinder were quite loose, the head of the hammer screw had sheared off and had been epoxied back in place, and the internal parts were worn out. What it did have in its favor was that, aside from the glued in hammer screw head, the revolver appeared to be in as-found, unmessed-with condition, sporting a consistent aged brown finish on all of its surfaces and scattered patches of rust that suggested that the parts that were there had been together for a long time; furthermore, one chamber in the cylinder was still loaded. Also going for it is the fact that the M1860 Colt, because of its graceful styling, is a beautiful gun regardless of of what condition it is found in. 

I bought the revolver with the intention of doing only what work was required to get it back to shooting condition. In other words, I wanted the final product to look its age, and to reflect the use and abuse that it had experienced over the years. After six or seven hours of scraping with a piece of brass to remove the scattered rust and clean out the assorted markings and tinkering to tighten up the barrel and cylinder, two orders to Dixie Gun Works for parts, and a little more time spent fitting the parts and adjusting the timing, the revolver turned out pretty good. It looks its age and still has all the wear, dents, dings and patina that it acquired over the last 150 or so years. Needless to say, I wasted no time in test firing it, which fortunately went without a hitch. As is apparent in the close-up pictures, the replacement screws and the trigger are rather obvious, but I will eventually get around to making them look a little less so without actually trying to hide the fact that they are not original to the gun.

In the process of cleaning and repairing an old gun such as this, you tend to get real familiar with it. Such was the case with this one. While it has mixed serial numbers, all fall within the first four years of production. This strikes me as a little odd. With production of the M1860 spread over twelve years and numbering in excess of 200,000 revolvers, I would expect at least one of the numbers to be over 100,000 unless the assorted parts were assembled into a revolver in the early years of the model's production. The trigger guard and back strap are numbered 6374, the frame is numbered 26582, and the barrel is numbered 89042, indicating production in 1861, 1862 and 1863, respectively. There is no number visible on the cylinder or the wedge. The barrel appears to have originally been on one of the approximately 130,000 U. S. military contract revolvers, as it bears two inspection marks, a 'W' on the right side of the lug and a 'SS' on the left side, as shown in the pictures on the left and right. The other parts appear to have been taken from civilian revolvers, as none has any markings that would indicate that they went through the government inspection process.

The trigger guard is quite unusual, as it is made of steel rather than the usual brass. Except for those revolvers made at Colt's London Armoury, I am not aware of any other Model 1860 Colts revolvers having steel trigger guards. The London Colts are typically in the 160,000 serial range or higher, so it is not likely that this trigger guard is from one of them.

We often hear someone make the statement 'If only it could talk' when looking at an old firearm. While this particular revolver comes up short of actually talking, it does provide a hint regarding its past. The grips are well-worn, and have the name Dick Ingersoll cut into the left side. I have no doubt that the grips are original to the grip frame based on the condition of the screw that attached the bottom of the backstrap to the trigger guard and the amount of work that was required to remove it. In addition, the condition of the carving suggests that it was present through most of the wear and tear that shows on the grips. An internet search yielded a George F. Ingersoll who went by the name Dick. He was born in 1858 in Lynn, Massachusetts, moved as a child with his family to Boone, Iowa in 1865, traveled with his father to the Black Hills during the 1875 gold strike, was employed in 1878 as a cow hand by the Lee-Scott Cattle Company of Fort Worth, Texas, was trail boss on cattle drives of Lee-Scott steers from Texas to Eastern Montana beginning in 1884, and eventually settled on the Bow-Gun Ranch in the vicinity of Terry, Montana. Perhaps George F. was the Dick Ingersoll who carved his name in the grip of the revolver, perhaps as a youngster growing up in Iowa, or later in the Black Hills gold diggings.

.

.