THE CARTRIDGE COLLECTOR'S EXCHANGE

Contents

Home

General Info

Ordering Info

Contact us

Cartridge Lists
Patent & Miscellaneous
Rim Fire
Center Fire Pistol
Center Fire Rifle
Metric Rimfire, Pistol&Rifle
British Pistol and Rifle
Shotgun Shells
Cartridge Boxes & Related

Posters

This Month's Picture Page

Index to Picture Pages

Prior Picture Pages:
 * September 2003
 
* October 2003
 
* November 2003
 
* December 2003                                     * January 2004
 
* February 2004
 
* March 2004
 
* April 2004
 
* May 2004
 
* June 2004
 
* July 2004
 
* August 2004
 
* September 2004
 
* October 2004
 
* November 2004
 
* December 2004
 
* January 2005
 
* February 2005
 
* March 2005
 
* April 2005
 
* May 2005
 
* June 2005
 
* July 2005
 
* August 2005
 
* September 2005
 
* October 2005
 
* November 2005
 
* December 2005
 
* January 2006
 
* February 2006
 
* March 2006
 
* April 2006
 
*May 2006
 
*June 2006
 
*July 2006
 
*August 2006
 
*September 2006
 
*October 2006
 
*November 2006
 
*December 2006
 
*January 2007
 
*February 2007
 
*March 2007
 
*April 2007
 
*May 2007
 
*June 2007
 
*July 2007
 
*August 2007
 
*September 2007
 
*October 2007
 
*November 2007
 
*December 2007
 
*January 2008
 
*February 2008
 
*March 2008
 
*April 2008
 
*May 2008
 
*June 2008
 
*July 2008
 
*August 2008
 
*September 2008
 
*October 2008
 
*November 2008
 
*December 2008
 
*January 2009
 
*February 2009
 
*March 2009
 
*April 2009
 
*May 2009
 
*June 2009
 
*July 2009
 
*August 2009
 
*September 2009
 
*October 2009
 
*November 2009
 
*December 2009
 
*January 2010
 
*February 2010
 
*March 2010
 
*April 2010
 
*May 2010
 
*June 2010
 
*July 2010
 
*August 2010
 
*September 2010
 
*October 2010
 
*November 2010
 
*December 2010
 
*January 2011
 
*February 2011
 
*March 2011
 There are no picture pages

for April thru June 2011
 
*July 2011
 
*August 2011
 
*September 2011
 
*October 2011
 
*November 2011
 
*December 2011
 
*January 2012
 
*February 2012
 
*March 2012
 
*April 2012
 
*May 2012
 
*June 2012
 
*July 2012
 
*August 2012

 *September 2012
 
*October 2012
 
*November 2012
 
*December 2012
 
*January 2013
 
*February 2013
 
*March 2013
 
*April 2013
 
*May 2013
 
*June 2013
 
*July 2013
 
*August 2013
 
*September 2013
 
*October 2013
 
*November 2013
 
*December 2013
 
*January 2014
 
*February 2014
 
*March 2014
 
*April 2014
 
*May 2014
 
*June 2014
 
*July 2014
 
*August 2014
 
*September 2014
 
*October 2014
 
*November 2014
 
*December 2014
 
*January 2015
 
*February 2015
 
 
 
Links to Other Sites     

Cartridge Collectors Organizations:
IAA
ECRA
SAAACA

Auctions:
Auction Arms
E-Bay
Ward's Collectibles
Sold USA

Books:
Armory Publications
WCF Publications

Other Collector's Sites:
Curtis Steinhauer

 

Home of the Old Ammo Guy's Virtual Cartridge Trading Table


Picture Page

March 2015


Bannerman's 1927 Military Goods Catalog.......

I purchased a collection of cartridges and reference materials this past month, and included in it were four editions of Francis Bannerman Sons Illustrated and Descriptive Catalogue of Military Goods from 1927, 1940, 1945 and 1949. The 1927 edition is 370 pages, nicely bound with black cloth covers and gold embossed lettering on the front and spine. The other three are stapled together, and haven't survived the wear and tear of the intervening years as well as the older bound edition. These Bannerman catalogs are a great source of information on arms and ammunition, as well as other mostly military items, as they provide detailed descriptions with historical background information, and quality illustrations or in some cases photographs for most of the items they sold. Francis Bannerman was born in Dundee, Scotland in March of 1851 to a family in which the tradition was to name the eldest son Francis, and he was the sixth in a line of so-named sons, his father also being one of those eldest sons named Francis. His family came to America in 1854, and found a home near the Brooklyn Navy Yard. Frank, as Francis Bannerman VI came to be known, attended school until the start of the Civil War, when his father enlisted in the Union Army and Frank had to withdraw from school at the age of ten to help support the family. He returned to school following his father's discharge from military service at the end of the war, but found little opportunity to attend full time due to the need to assist his father in his ship chandlery store, which grew out of a scavenged junk business to one that was eventually purchasing military goods at US Navy auctions, primarily worn rope for resale to paper makers. In 1872, with his father's blessing, Frank set up a naval surplus goods business in competition with his father. At an early age he had observed old military muskets and swords being destroyed for scrap, and knowing that there was demand for these old weapons in smaller countries that were unable to afford modern weapons, he began attending Army auctions and buying up these obsolete weapons. He was also aware that many of these weapons had historical significance and were worthy of preservation. As a result, he began publishing his catalog, illustrating and providing the history of the weapons he had to sell. A New York Sun reporter wrote that "Bannerman could tell an interesting story about everything he had for sale". His catalog is given much of the credit for the beginning of gun collecting among the middle class in this country, who previously only purchased guns that were needed for food or protection. Over the next 25 years, Bannerman's developed into the world's largest seller of surplus military equipment, and the growth of his business required several moves to gain needed storage space. At the start of the Spanish-American War in 1897, Bannerman's salesroom and warehouse was at 501 Broadway in New York City. From this location, they outfitted many of the American volunteer regiments. As the war wound down they purchased weapons directly from the Spanish government before it evacuated Cuba, and then purchased 90% of the guns, ammunition and equipment captured by the US military and auctioned off by the government. These purchases necessitated that Frank Bannerman find a remote location to safely store the 30 million (give or take a few million) cartridges and artillery projectiles that he had obtained. He purchased Polopels Island in the Hudson River in 1900 for this purpose, upon which he had constructed storehouses and a summer residence, all patterned after the castles in his native Scotland. In the side of the largest castle-like storehouse were the words "Bannerman's Island Arsenal". Consequently, the island became known as Bannerman's Island, and the largest structure, Bannerman's Castle. They continued to maintain the 501 Broadway location as their retail outlet and showroom. Construction was ongoing on the island until Bannerman's death in 1918. In August 1920, two hundred tons of artillery shells and powder exploded destroying the powder house. State and Federal firearms legislation severely impacted sales to civilians over the years, and by 1957, Bannerman's island was pretty much abandoned. In 1958, Frank Bannerman's grandchildren had the remaining ordnance on the island removed, allowed the Smithsonian to select items for the museum collection, and auctioned off the remaining items, The State of New York took ownership of the island and buildings in 1967, and tours of the island were conducted beginning in 1968. On August 8, 1969, a fire began in the Arsenal and over the next three days destroyed the roof and floors, leaving just the walls standing. Today the Arsenal is in ruins, with much of the structure remaining after the fire having collapsed..

.

This page shows a view of the 'Bannerman's Island Arsenal', the most prominent building on Polepel's Island. This is the building that burned in 1969.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

 

.

.

This is one of several pages devoted primarily to cartridges, however, cartridges are also scattered throughout the firearms sections of the catalog, listed with the specific weapons that were chambered for them.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

From the left column of the page shown above are these cartridges, including the W.R.A.Co.  .45-70 U.S.G. headstamped example, of which Bannerman had 7 million. I can't begin to imagine 350,000 boxes of Winchester .45-70. The Springfield musket and Gallager's carbine cartridges at 10 cents each sound like a great deal, but considering these are 1927 prices when a new Ford Model T could be had for under $400, puts these cartridge prices into perspective. 

.

.

.

.

These cartridges are pictured on the upper right of the page shown above. Again, great prices for Spencer, Evans and Maynard cartridges from today's perspective. The Evans shot cartridge is quite unusual, with it's paper bullet. I believe these are attributed to the Phoenix Metallic Cartridge Company, which held the patent for the shot-filled segmented paper bullet.  

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

 

 

.

.

.

.

.

Another of the pages devoted primarily to cartridges. The descriptions usually include some historical facts related to the cartridges being sold, including where and under what circumstances they were obtained. These facts were included by Bannerman to give the cartridges some intrinsic (collector) value over and above their value as shooting ammunition.

.

.

.

.

.

 

The most interesting item to me on the page shown above to is the set of six Spanish War cartridges, ranging from battlefield pickups, cartridges damaged in shipping or at sea,  or captured in war. Note the 'Poisoned Bullet' reference to the Spanish Reformado cartridge, a misnomer that originated as a result of the green verdigris that is usually found on their brass jacketed bullets and resulted from the reaction of the bullet lubricant with the brass jacket. At $1.50 for the six, or 25 cents each, these seem to be rather pricey compared to other cartridges in the catalog.

.

.

.

.

.

Two cartridges that appear out of place in a military goods catalog are these, also from the page shown above. The upper one is the 32-40 Ballard and the lower one the .38-40 Remington Straight; both seem reasonably priced at about 1.5 cents per cartridge. 

.

.

..

Another page with diagrams and descriptions of paper cartridges loaded with a round ball and a Minie bullet.

.

.

.

.

.

.

 

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.